Taking Your Tooth Fairy Game to the Next Level

The days of a dollar slipped under the pillow are long gone, friends. Today, the Tooth Fairy has tools comparable to the likes of Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny for creating wonder and excitement for your littles as they loose those sweet baby teeth.

Here are our top picks for taking your Tooth Fairy Game to the next level:

Expert Tip: Images Hyperlinked for easy Purchase.

Favorite Pottery Barn Kids picks:

Pottery Barn Kids added swashbuckling style to this molar pillow to make losing a tooth extra exciting. Tuck the lost tooth into the pirate patch so it will be easy for the Tooth Fairy to find. 6.5″ wide x 7″ high Made of polyester canvas. Polyester fill. Features contrast stitching along edges. Eye patch doubles as a pocket for the tooth. In Store Pick-up Only (I just saw 6 at Stonebriar Mall in Frisco, TX)

This pillow is the exact one that we purchased for our girls. Also available in stripe for your little men! In-Store Pick-up Only. Currently available at Stonebriar Mall in Frisco, Texas.

“Who is the Tooth Fairy? Where does she come from? And why does she like to collect teeth? There are many legends and stories that have been told including quite a few made up on the spot by clever moms and dads but it can be tricky for parents who want to offer a real answer to their children’s boundless questions. From top to bottom, this kit was designed to give parents and children alike the answers to these mysterious questions. And to help soothe any fears that little ones may have about losing their teeth.

Also Recommended:

$20.99 with your fave toothless kiddo's name

Personalized tooth fairy pillow with golden crown and ice cream by MamaTutFelt on Etsy

8.5" wide x 11" high Hardcover. 32 pages. Ages 5 and up.

A self-described “action kind of gal,” this Tooth Fairy lives for danger and suspense as she gathers up kids’ teeth while they sleep, and leaves coins in their places. Buy

Beginning readers will love Pete's adventure as the tooth fairy in this My First I Can Read story

In Pete the Cat and the Lost Tooth, the tooth fairy asks Pete for some help. But it’s not easy being the tooth fairy for Pete when a tooth goes missing—will he be able to find the lost tooth before it’s too late? Buy

Literally cannot get enough of this Unicorn Tooth Fairy Pillow by MamaTutFelt on Etsy. Only TWO left!

Teeth Fairies is a new spin on the tooth fairy tradition. It is a brand new book and doll set that provides a fun interactive experience between your child and their own personal tooth fairy. The Teeth Fairies box set contains an adorable fairy and beautifully illustrated hard cover book with pages that can be personalized. The final page offers a tooth chart, where the date, tooth number, and surprise left by the fairy can all be listed. Teeth Fairies is a family keepsake. Kids lose over 20 baby teeth, so the set is meant to be used again and again to provide lasting memories and loads of fun for you and your children. *Winner of the 2015 National Parenting Publication Silver Award. Shop